The Trap of Overthinking
There’s a moment, maybe it happens today or maybe it happens every day, where you freeze.
You have something to say, build, and launch, but instead of doing it, you think. Then think about thinking, and then think about how you’re thinking too much.
You call it being careful, or being strategic, or not wanting to seem arrogant.
You’re not scared of how others will judge you.
You’re terrified of what you already believe about yourself.
Overthinking is Fear in Disguise
You’re not overthinking because you’re deep or wise. You’re overthinking because you’re scared. You’re stuck in an endless loop of self-judgment, calling it caution. You’ve built a perfect version of yourself to sell to the world, but the real you is trapped and terrified to show up.
Instead of embracing the discomfort of growth, you put up barriers of logic.
You convince yourself that you need more time to think.
More research. More validation. More preparation.
Overthinking is your mind’s desperate attempt to avoid facing the fear of inadequacy and failure.
More Thinking Only Creates More Paralysis
This is where the trap is set.
You think more will solve the problem. You try to think your way out of overthinking, but you can’t think your way out of fear. When you overthink, you create a mental prison that grows tighter every time you try to break out.
You start to rationalize the paralysis. You think it’s about being responsible, thoughtful, or strategic, but in reality, you’re just stalling and making excuses. You’ve convinced yourself that not doing anything is safer than risking rejection or failure.
“Your doubts are killing more of your dreams than failure ever did.” —Vin Jay
Overthinking doesn’t protect you. It only locks you in a cycle of self-doubt. So you act like you’re being wise or mature, but you’re not. You’re just scared.
Scared of being seen.
Scared of being wrong.
Scared of being exposed as the man who tried and still wasn’t enough.
You’re not stuck because you don’t know enough.
You’re stuck because you’re afraid to find out what happens when you finally bet on yourself.
Action Is the Key That Breaks the Chains
The antidote = Action!
Not some perfect action.
Not some well-planned, well-executed strategy.
The kind of action that feels messy, unpolished, and full of risk. The kind where you press record before you feel ready. You speak up in that Zoom, even if your throat tightens. It’s the moment you pick up the phone and make the call you’ve avoided for years. It’s when you stop censoring yourself to be “likable.” It’s when you stop performing and start being.
You don’t need permission.
You don’t need approval.
You don’t need everything to be perfect.
You need movement.
But I’m not just talking about getting your steps in or grinding out another set at the gym. I’m talking about the kind of movement that cracks your chest open. The movement that forces you to confront your fears, shame, and silence. It’s the step you take when everything in your nervous system screams “don’t.”
It’s when you walk straight into the fire, not because you’re fearless, but because you’re done letting fear run your life. Every time you take action that aligns with your deeper self, you bury the boy who was afraid to disappoint everyone and start becoming the man who no longer hides.
Every single time you take that imperfect step, you defy the voice inside that says, “Wait. Think more. Don’t mess up.”
Truth Isn’t Found by Thinking More
Truth isn’t just something you figure out. It’s something you feel. Something you live.
Many people think truth is something you arrive at after enough intellectual effort, as if they think hard enough, gather enough data, and analyze every angle, they’ll finally arrive at some clean, logical conclusion that tells them who they are and what to do.
But truth doesn’t come from spreadsheets and overanalysis. It lives in your body. It lives in your gut, your heart, your breath. It shows up when you stop trying to be “right” and start being honest, even if it hurts.
Yes, thinking has its place, but it’s not the best tool for accessing the kind of deep, personal truth you need to move forward. Because the truth that sets you free isn’t found through thinking, it’s found through:
Intuition: That gut feeling, of knowing that bypasses all the logic and noise. It’s not always explainable, but some of the most important moves you’ll ever make will come from a place you can’t explain. Not from logic, but from clarity.
Emotion: When your emotions are clear, not distorted by trauma, fear, or guilt, they point you toward your deepest truths. But you won’t trust yourself if you’ve spent your life numbing, suppressing, or judging what you feel. You’ll second-guess every instinct. You’ll call it “being rational” when really, you’re just scared to feel.
Truth isn’t a puzzle to solve, it’s an experience you let in. If you can’t access your emotional world, you’ll keep living a life that looks stable on the outside but is built on lies. A life that feels “safe” but quietly eats you alive.
Trauma and Fear of Exposure
Overthinking isn’t about being careful or strategic; it’s about survival.
For a lot of men, the root of overthinking is trauma. Not always the big, dramatic kind, but the slow erosion of self-trust that happens when you’re constantly judged, shamed, ignored, or made to feel like your feelings are a problem.
Emotional wounds from the past sever your connection to your own intuition and emotions. You don’t trust your gut, and you don’t trust what you feel. So you compensate by living in your head and analyzing every move, calculating every risk, searching for the “perfect” answer that never comes.
Over time, you learn to disconnect from your emotions. You stop trusting your instincts. You learn it’s safer to stay in your head, to analyze, plan, and hesitate, because the moment you act, you risk being seen.
Beneath all the thinking is our fear of being exposed.
What if you take action and the world sees the real you?
What if they see your flaws and imperfections and reject you?
What if you confirm your deepest fear, that you’re not enough?
This is the deepest fear of many men. They don’t fear failure as much as they fear exposure. The truth that, deep down, they don’t believe they’re good enough. So they avoid risk and avoid action because it’s the logical choice.
You’re not lazy.
You don’t have a lack of desire.
You aren’t lacking meaning or purpose.
It’s a nervous system that was trained to associate action and vulnerability with danger. So you overthink, delay, and tell yourself you’re being “smart” or “careful,” but really, you’re just trying to avoid the pain of being fully seen and possibly rejected.
Confidence isn’t Found, it’s Built
Every time you act in the face of fear, you prove yourself wrong.
You prove that the story you’ve been carrying, the one that says you’re not ready, you’re not good enough, you’ll mess it up, is a lie.
Most men think confidence is something you either have or you don’t. Like it’s a personality trait you were born with. Either you’re the guy who can handle things, or you’re not. But confidence doesn’t work like that.
It’s not gifted. It’s earned.
It’s forged through doing, not thinking.
You don’t need to wait for permission.
You don’t need to plan more.
You need to show up, and keep showing up.
If this hits something in you, if you’re tired of hiding behind overthinking, and you’re ready to start living like a man who trusts himself, then stop trying to do it alone.
Inside the Fraternity of Excellence, men are doing the work, facing their fears, confronting their stories, and getting the support needed to take action.
Join us, and surround yourself with men who refuse to let fear dictate their lives.
The door is open. Walk through it. Start showing up for your life.
👉 Join the Fraternity of Excellence
FoE Event in Georgia last month!
